Law #12 says the merch line during the opener tells you everything about the tour. It tells you something, but probably not what it looks like. At club-to-arena shows in the US and the UK, a long line while the support act plays says more about how the night was packaged than about the support act. People don't buy tickets to see the opener. The opening slot gets filled for reasons other than selling tickets, sometimes a straight deal where the opener paid to be on the bill and got a merch table as part of it. And the venue's cut of every shirt, commonly 20 to 25 percent in the US, gives both acts a reason to sell hard in the one stretch of the night when the headliner's crowd is inside and the headliner isn't on yet. Nobody has published when in the night merch actually sells, though, so this is a pattern fans see, not a peak anyone has measured.
Nobody bought a ticket for the opener
The best evidence on that is a study of 57 opening artists by Jeff Apruzzese of Drexel University, published in the MEIEA journal in February 2025, which concluded audiences may not buy tickets specifically to see openers. In a survey of 525 people that Drexel published alongside it, knowing who the opener was generally didn't change whether they bought a ticket, though 68 percent said they'd discovered new bands that way.
So people like finding a band in the support slot, but the support slot isn't what sold the room. That's the part that matters for the merch line. If the opener isn't there to move tickets, somebody put them there for another reason, and you weren't consulted.
Sometimes the reason is money going the wrong way. In November 2016 Digital Music News reported a promoter selling fifteen minutes before Cam'ron, plus a merch table next to his at every venue, for $800. In 2014 Gig City's Mike Ross wrote about Scott Fox, who paid Combichrist $400 a show to open 27 European dates and sold $300 to $800 in merch a night, and quoted a booking agent saying the buy-on is "not the norm." Two cases don't tell you how often it happens, and I couldn't find anything on the record about how support slots usually get filled, whether by agents, labels or the headliner's own pick. It does tell you a merch table is something a support act can be sold, and that for a band paying to be there, the table is where the fee has to come back from. On Fox's slow nights, it didn't.
The venue takes its share first
In any building that charges a merch fee, every shirt reaches the band already cut. Billboard's June 2024 piece on merch fees called 20 to 25 percent the industry standard, and reported that Madison Square Garden takes 30 percent plus card fees. In the UK, Featured Artists Coalition chief executive David Martin wrote in Music Week in January 2023 that venue commissions frequently amount to 25 percent of gross, plus VAT.
When a quarter of the money's gone before you've paid for the shirts, you need volume. Volume needs a crowd standing near the table with nothing else to do. Derek Ball, who runs the merch sales company atVenu, put the job this way in a 2023 interview: the doors open and "you have 90 minutes to sell T-shirts to 14,000 people." The opener plays inside those 90 minutes. It's the one stretch where the headliner's fans can buy a shirt without missing anything they paid for, and where a support act with its own table is set up beside the busiest stall in the building.
That's why I'd read a long line at that point as the business of the night showing through. It's the headliner's crowd, in the only window the schedule gives them, with both acts selling into it because the cut leaves them a thin margin. It tells you who's paying for whom more than it tells you whether the opener's any good.
The places that scrapped the fee, and the count nobody's run
Some rooms already work without the cut. Live Nation said in March 2024 that its On the Road Again clubs in the US don't charge merch selling fees. That's the clubs, not the arenas. In the UK, Martin said more than 550 venues had signed up to the FAC's 100% Venues campaign within 12 months.
Those are the natural tests of this law, and I couldn't find a single number from any of them. Nobody's published whether merch sales per head went up in the no-fee clubs, or whether the line moved to a different part of the night once the cut was gone. The same goes for the fact underneath the whole thing. I found no published data on what time of night merch sells, at any size of room. atVenu has written about selling "during peak windows" without saying when those are. So the law is reading what you see from the floor, not a peak anyone has counted.
And there's a reading of that same line that turns the law around. A survey by UTA and Variety, reported by Hypebot in October 2023, found 68 percent of concertgoers said they get to the venue early specifically to see the opening acts, and 30 percent said they'd bought an opener's merch. I couldn't find the original report, and Hypebot gives no sample size, so it's one survey of what people say they do. It's also the same 68 percent as Drexel's figure for fans who found new bands through openers, and I can't rule out that it's that finding misreported rather than a separate one. But if it's anywhere near right, a lot of the people in that line during the support set are the opener's own fans buying the opener's own shirt. That's a line about the opener after all.
Sources(10)Show allHide
- Jeff Apruzzese, "Did You Catch The Opener?…Exploring the Transformative Dynamics of Opening Performances: A Quantitative Analysis on Streaming for Emerging Artists", Journal of the Music and Entertainment Industry Educators Association 24(1), 3 February 2025, reference-global.com
- Drexel News, "What's the Benefit of Opening for Taylor Swift?", 17 April 2025, drexel.edu
- Digital Music News, Daniel Sanchez, "Want to Open for Cam'ron? A 15 Minute Slot Costs $800", 14 November 2016, digitalmusicnews.com
- Gig City, Mike Ross, "Your favourite band sucks: The secret shame of the 'buy-on'", 13 May 2014, gigcity.ca
- Billboard, "Inside the Growing War Over Merch Fees at Venues", 1 June 2024, billboard.com
- Music Week, David Martin (Featured Artists Coalition), "Featured Artists Coalition CEO urges live sector to back campaign against excessive merch commission", 11 January 2023, musicweek.com
- Audience Republic, "atVenu's Derek Ball: 13 Ways To Increase Your Merch Sales in 2023", 22 March 2023, audiencerepublic.com
- Live Nation Entertainment, "Live Nation's On The Road Again Has Supported 4,000+ Developing Artists & Will Continue Rolling Through 2024", 12 March 2024, news.livenationentertainment.com
- atVenu, "What's Actually Driving Record Merch Sales at Live Events", 3 March 2026, atvenu.com
- Hypebot, Bruce Houghton, "Fans care about openers, says survey. But for acts, is bigger better?", 30 October 2023, hypebot.com