Still Ringing · Issue · venues

A Crowd Is Not a Community

Lollapalooza's rainy surprise-guest weekend, two beloved small rooms reopening, and the Long Take on what a venue actually loses when it goes multi-purpose.

·Updated ·6 min read·By Still Ringing

The rain started during the Smashing Pumpkins' headline set, and Billy Corgan used it. He waved out a very special guest and Olivia Rodrigo walked on to trade verses on "Thirty-Three", a 1996 deep cut the band had not touched since 2018; Yungblud fronted "Luna" an hour later, and original bassist Melissa Auf der Maur came back for the closer. The same Lollapalooza weekend, Lorde brought Charli XCX out for "Girl, So Confusing" on her first Grant Park stage since 2017, and SB19 became the first all-Filipino act to play the festival. None of it was posted to a venue account an hour before doors. That is the kind of surprise you cannot pre-sell, which is the only kind worth standing in the rain for.

The Long Take

What a small venue actually loses when it goes multi-purpose

Blaze Wenglikowski's favorite night on a stage was at Piere's in Fort Wayne, singing next to his father. On August 3 the room closed, the owners blaming rising costs and more than a hundred police calls since 2024. He had a GoFundMe up to build a new all-ages room before the week was out.

Stop mourning the small venue as a lost community. The dive bar with three good shows a week was never a community. It was a small revolving crowd telling itself it was one.

What actually died is smaller and more exact: the band that always plays here. You cannot grow a regular act in a room that runs comedy on Tuesday, a DJ on Wednesday, and a touring indie band on Thursday. The booking calendar has no memory.

A house band needs a house.

The independent-venue crisis behind this is real. NIVA spent the pandemic years counting rooms that went dark and never came back, and the closures never fully stopped.

Piere's is one line in a long list.

The rooms that do come back rarely come back as scenes. Two reopened this very month, both kept live music, and neither can promise you the same band next month.

The honest objection is that a multi-purpose room serves more people. Comedy night pays the rent that keeps the lights on for Thursday's band.

True.

But it serves more crowds, not more scenes. A crowd buys a ticket and leaves. A scene is the ten people who were in that room every week, and you cannot route your way back to those ten.

The room can reopen. The regulars scattered two years ago, and nobody sends a save-the-date for that.

A crowd, not a community.

Concert Law number 10 card.

Concert Law #10: The room you saw a band in the first time is the room you remember them in forever.

Concert Law №10
The room you saw a band in the first time is the room you remember them in forever.

This Week in Shows

Two of Lollapalooza's four days went to the weather. Overnight storms flooded Grant Park, gates slipped to 3 p.m. Saturday while crews pumped out the field, and by Sunday the app that sells you a lineup was pushing evacuation alerts and garage shelter sites. Set it next to Post Malone's Edmonton stadium show washing out last week and the pattern sharpens: the festival calendar keeps writing checks the sky won't cash.

Barry Manilow pushed his Lexington date a second time. He moved the Rupp Arena show off August 4 citing only "unforeseen circumstances," the same night he already rescheduled back in March. No reason has been confirmed, so we won't guess at one; the concrete part is the ticket-holder who booked a hotel and a sitter twice for a show that keeps sliding. Here's hoping the third date holds.

The big rooms are lit again. Foo Fighters opened their 2026 stadium run in Toronto on August 4, and AC/DC's Power Up tour hit Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas on August 1. Neither is news by announcement and both are old routings finally landing, but after a spring thick with cancellations, the stadium slate is just happening.

The Venue Report

Two rooms came back this month. In Portland, the old Landmark Saloon reopened as the Switchback Saloon after two longtime regulars, Scott Phillips and Graham Talley, bought it with the former owner's blessing and kept the small stage for regional acts. In Pittsburgh, Club Cafe, a 25-year South Side room that went dark in 2024, threw a four-day reopening under Keystone Artist Connect. Both saves came from inside the scene, not from a chain buying a logo. In a year that already took Oakland's New Parish and is winding down Bottom of the Hill, two rooms measured in somebody's memory got the lights back on. That counts for something, even if it doesn't count for everything.

500,000

Total attendance at the original Woodstock in 1969. The organizers had planned for fifty thousand.

Then

Thirty years ago this week, on August 10 and 11, 1996, Oasis played to roughly 250,000 people across two nights at Knebworth, the weekend Britpop hit its peak and started the slow descent. It reads differently now that the Gallaghers actually reunited and toured in 2025, with promoters floating a 30th-anniversary Knebworth return the band keeps publicly denying. A field of a quarter million people, almost none of them holding a phone over their head. Then versus now more or less writes itself.

Fan Debate

Usher pulled a woman onstage in Nashville for the slow-dance serenade, read that she did not want to be there, and quietly ended the bit before it curdled. She went viral defending herself, saying she came for Chris Brown and Chris Brown only, and by the Birmingham date Usher had turned the whole thing into a nightly line about not coming up if you don't want to be up there. He handled the live moment about as well as anyone could, which is exactly why it reopened the older question. The bring-a-stranger-onstage move, the serenade, the slow dance: is any of it worth the nights the stranger is miserable up there? Reply and tell Jake whether the tradition should retire, or whether reading the room the way Usher did is the entire skill.

The Practical Bit

The wave of ticket-resale price caps you have been hearing about is stalling. TicketNews reports that roughly thirteen resale bills failed to advance in 2026 amid a coordinated lobbying push, which means the relief a lot of states promised is dying in committee before it reaches your checkout. Watch your own state's bill, not the national headline.

B-Sides

A fan's climb for a close-up ends in a tumble. At the Usher and Chris Brown stop in Birmingham, a fan scaled the seat-backs to film Chris Brown up close, lost her footing, and went down between the rows with nothing hurt but her pride. Somewhere in that clip is the entire phones argument, no commentary required.

CORTIS ask you to put the phone down, literally. The rookie K-pop group launched a world tour named "Put Your Phone Down," asking fans to stop filming and be in the room, and the internet answered, predictably, with footage of the opposite.

Little Feat stretch the goodbye. The band added August dates to their "Last Farewell" run, proving again that a farewell tour is rarely as final as the poster.

The last time I saw a band in the little room off the highway, the singer knew three people in the crowd by name, and two of them were working the bar.

The Bit

The best kind of stage disaster is the one nobody planned and nobody got hurt in. At Coachella in 2018, during "Get Me Bodied," Beyoncé went to scoop up Solange the way she had the weekend before. The heels lost, both Knowles sisters hit the stage at the same time, kicked their legs straight up in unison like it was choreography, laughed it off, and Solange skipped away while the set never once stopped.

Some rooms close and some rooms reopen, and both are worth showing up for while they're standing.

Still Ringing lands free in your inbox every Wednesday. Subscribe and tell Jake where he's wrong.

See you at the show. Jake

The Newsletter

Still Ringing

Weekly issues on Wednesdays, deep cuts on Thursdays. The stuff worth knowing before you buy tickets — free, straight to your inbox.